Archive for the ‘Security Issues’ Category

US Airport Security

Sunday, May 16th, 2010

Have you ever arrived home from the US to discover that the contents of your suitcase have been inspected by US security officials? Luggage at US airports, and most other major airports around the world.  is routinely scanned before loading and, especially in the US, it is also subject to additional random checks. These checks can be annoying but we accept them in the name of safety. So, how could an American citizen of Egyptian birth, be arrested when he arrived at Cairo on a flight from New York last week when it was discovered his case contained two pistols, 250 bullets and 11 knives?

We accept mistakes can happen – though this is a fairly major mistake – but the response of the US authorities is far more worrying. Their explanation appears to be limited to stating that it is not illegal in the US to carry firearms in checked luggage.

Security lapses occur anywhere, though too many seem to be occurring in the US, but it is the lazy attitude of the authorities that is most disturbing. Nothing is ever their fault.

Just imagine the huge fuss the Americans would make if a passenger arrived in New York on an Egyptair flight from Cairo with the same items in his luggage. There would be hell to pay both in terms of massively increased checks on Egyptair aircraft and their passengers and wild tabloid headlines about bad security outside the US.

However, when the Americans are caught napping, we are meant to turn a blind eye.

Maybe we should remember that part of the reason for the success of 9/11 was the fact that US airport security was so much worse than in most other countries. Despite all the officiousness of US security staff, has anything actually changed?

One Expert Opinion We Don’t Need

Thursday, February 25th, 2010

I had thought that it was only the saintly Michael O’Leary of Ryanair whose opinion on all matters regarding aviation was to be regarded as infalliable but now it seems the Pope wants to get in on the act.

In a speech to Alitalia workers Pope Benedict XVI criticised the use of full-body scanners at airports and said it is important “to protect the human person in their integrity” and that “human dignity must be preserved”.

There are certainly questions to be answered about the use of full-body scanners:

- Do they actually give the full protection against smuggled objects that is promised?

- Do they pose any form of long-term health risk?

The jury is out on both questions and there are plenty of people who suggest the installation of these machines at UK airports was just a knee-jerk political stunt to show “government in action” but which fails to solve the problem. Hopefully, those questions will be answered in due course and it can be judged whether the machines have any benefit. However, the Pope’s intervention on the matter is thoroughly unhelpful.

Of course we should preserve “human dignity” but preserving life by making air travel safer takes precedent in any sane world. If – and it is a big if – these machines fulfill that purpose then travellers will just have to live with them.

The Pope seems to have copied Michael O’Leary’s tactic of making questionable comments to get publicity. Airline security is not a religious issue and relgious leaders should leave the matter to the experts.  If the Pope wants to get involved in aviation, maybe he should concentrate on praying for Alitalia’s revival.

Going to Bangkok this week?

Tuesday, February 23rd, 2010

Did you know that authorities in Bangkok are seriously concerned about the possibility of civil unrest in Bangkok?

The great British press is incredibly insular in its outlook. We have all the news we could possibly want about such surprising facts that wealthy footballers sometimes cheat on their wives, that Gordon Brown has a bad temper and that the Pope is celibate but when it comes to overseas news, there can be stunning silence. Even the terrible rail crash in Brussels last week failed to make most of the British front pages. The strange workings of politics in Thailand are most unlikely to appear even in the quality press – unless there is another airport blockade when you can be sure there will be non-stop coverage of plucky British tourists bemoaning their fate.

On 26th February the Supreme Court of Thailand is due to rule on the seizure of assets of the disgraced ex-Prime Minister, Thakan Shinowatra and it is feared this could be the trigger for widespread disturbance if supporters of the two opposing sides take to the streets. The Tourist Authority of Thailand is said to have made contingency plans and suggested that some local operators move tourists away from Bangkok. The Australian government has a travel advisory in place and there is a note on the Thailand page of the UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office site (www.fco.gov.uk) but we imagine nearly all British travellers leaving for Thailand this week are doing so in ignorance. In general, we think it is always a good idea to take an occasional look at the FCO site and, when you are visiting a country outside Europe, it really does pay to do a quick Google search for the local English language newspapers and check the current news. Bangkok has two papers, The Nation and The Bangkok Post and even a cursory glance at either would have alerted you to the fact that “something is happening”.

We certainly cannot pretend to be experts in Thai politics and we would not wish to predict what might happen. However, experience suggests that when problems like this are anticipated, they fail to materialise. Bangkok is a very big city and  a small riot can be happening in one part of the city without impacting life in the rest of the city. It could be that the atmosphere in the streets might be a little tense and we imagine some of the night venues might close early. Somehow we doubt that protesters will try to blockade the airports again because this is an old trick and the authorities will be prepared. However, if the worst predictions do come true, we will find it a little difficult to have sympathy for stranded British tourists who haven’t bothered to do even the slightest homework on their destination.

Update:

Regardless of the Court’s verdict, supporters of the ex-Prime Minister intend to hold a rally in Bangkok on 14th March. They say up to a million people might descend on Bangkok from the countryside. Regardless of possible violence, this would seem like a day to avoid – Bangkok’s traffic is bad at the best of times.

Ryanair’s spot of Italian bother

Monday, January 4th, 2010

A story rumbling around in the background of the festive season has been Ryanair’s row with the Italian government over ID requirements on its Italian domestic services. The airline is threatening to stop domestic flights in Italy from 23rd January amid a dispute with the country’s authorities over new rules on ID documents that passengers must show before boarding. Last month, Italy’s civil aviation authority ordered all airlines to accept driving licences, government badges and hunting licences amongst other documents to identify passengers at boarding gates for domestic flights. Ryanair responded that the documents on the government list were less secure and threatened flight security. Ryanair says that because it operates a near 100% online check-in system, passengers are asked at booking time to show their passport or identity card before boarding. BusinessWeek has the full story.

So what is going on here? It would be entirely true to form if a substantial part of the Italian civil aviation authority’s motivation is to defend the position of Italy’s own airlines – all of whom would happily accept your DVD rental card as valid ID. But what of Ryanair’s selflessness? Some might say that its stringent ID requirements, required by the airline wherever it operates, have actually quite a lot to do with stopping individuals reselling surplus tickets through auction sites, and companies bulk-buying cheap tickets months in advance on routes frequently flown by their employees.

Whatever the motivation it could get nasty. Both sides in the Italian row seem to be digging in, and Ryanair’s Italian network is fairly substantial.

In other Ryanair news it was amusing to see the UK’s OFT chief slamming the airline’s fees for online card payments as “puerile”. If the OFT honcho fully appreciated the attractions of the prepaid debit card that Ryanair will accept without fee, he might have been a little more charitable.